This goes along with what I have learned over the course of hte last year since I started down this road....
"It's never quite that easy."
Ever see the movie "The Edge"? You know the role that Anthony Hopkins plays? He's reading that survival book and finds it very interesting. He learns a lot, like how to make a compass with a needle and silk.
So, he uses that trick with the needle, and it works, except they end up going in a big circle because of his metal belt buckle.
It's just not that easy.
Which is why things like starting your first wet fire feels like an accomplishment..... .because it is!
For the record though....shavings are shavings....they don't have to be on the stick to work, the fire doesn't care. You can still use them...but curls are not as easy to start with a ferro rod as people think, either, until you do it yourself.
What I do, is I actually shave off some of my ferro rod so as not to ignite it, and let it sprinkle onto the shavings like cinnamon, THEN I strike the ferro rod. Usually works....not always.